Okay, I don't have all 40 in the set. And I likely never will - like most people, I'm not made of money - but if the two sets I purchased are anything to go by, this minis set is still well worth the price. Yeah, there are fewer minis in the set, but overall they're of better quality, both in sturdiness and in paint quality.
The two rares - a war devil and a unicorn - were very good and very useful. Others have commented that the war devil is kind of cartoony, and I can see how others might think that but, honestly, the malebranche has always been kind of a corny critter, ripped right from the medieval pages of texts on hellish bad guys. The unicorn is excellent. It's gray with white spots, rather than pure white or some random fantasy colour, and looks like something that might actually be threatening.
The jewel of my sets is definitely the Bonechill Chimera, which is just gorgeous. chimeras are one of my favourite monsters anyway, but this one's going to be hitting the battlemap, and soon, as a featured monster.
Others have complained that a lot of the minis are reboots - a new orc, a new gnoll, etc. - but I like that. Now I have figures I can use for an orc squad leader or lieutenant, and a different kind of mini I can use for grunts.
Overall, a very good set, and one where I'll try hard to get a complete set.