73 internautes sur 81 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile
Athena and Jason
- Publié sur Amazon.com
First off, I must say that I'm here at Amazon to order "Rules of Order, Newly Revised" (RONR), 11th edition, so I have not yet laid my eager hands on the most current edition of group decision-making sanity. Therefore, the four stars are based on the quality of Edition 10 and the apparency that the missing and duplicate pages situation is handled. God Bless and hats off to Henry M. Roberts. This review is for /authentic/ Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised. I hope to dispel some potential frustration and share some key factors in choosing a parliamentary reference book.
SOME KEY PRINCIPLES
1. A well-written set of By-Laws will refer to a specific edition of Robert's Rules. For example "Meetings shall be conducted according to Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised, 11th Edition." With many knock-off and competing publications out there, having everyone singing from the same exact hymnal can make a HUGE difference. If you have some other reference, you're going to have double difficulty (rightly so) when you try to cite your copy's version of Robert's Rules. It's far better if everyone is using the same edition because it is a basis for agreement. (More later on the importance of agreement.)
2. Many other "Robert's Rules" publications are heavily based on past editions of the Official Robert's Rules that have now passed into the public domain and are available to be shamelessly copied and repackaged as something new. That's fair game under copyright law, but I think it's doing buyers a grave disservice to issue a century-old or decades-old edition as if it were something current. Get the most current edition unless there's a really good reason to get the 10th edition, such as operating under by-laws that have adopted a specific older edition. I'd say get that edition and get the most current one, also, so you're prepared when there's a question about something like meetings via phone or votes via e-mail.
The key to successful, productive meetings that forward the work of the overall group is AGREEMENT. Disagreement is the poison that will throw a Board of Directors or a meetings of a general membership into chaos and leave everyone frazzled, frustrated, and decidedly NOT looking forward to taking on Committee work. ANY well-though-out system will make a tremendous difference compared to a partial system or, God forbid, no system at all. Robert's Rules of Order is the tried and true system for running productive meetings.
3. If you're getting the message from the two items above, you should now be doubtful about such titles as "Robert's Rules for Dummies", "The Guerilla Guide to Robert's Rules", etc.. (By the way, the "Guerilla Guide" is a horrible idea as it can cause great harm to others' goodwill for you if you aren't a professional parliamentarian and know exactly how to apply the tactics without being an abhorrent nuisance. It can get you barred from participating and even thrown out of the meeting or even thrown out of the group or association holding the meeting; the procedure for throwing out a nuisance member is also covered in Robert's Rules.)
So what do you do about digesting the material and making it your own?
Well, Robert's Rules are complex if you try to take on the whole system at once. That's where Robert's Rules in Brief comes in. Robert's Rules in Brief is a complete introduction to Robert's Rules that will have you up and running quicker than you think--if you study it and really decide to learn and apply what's in this wonderful little book. And I don't mean "little" in the endearing sense. It really is quite small, portable, and approachable.
The best part of starting with Robert's Rules in Brief is that it refers you to the exact location in the full edition for more information. this means that you can practice the concepts and procedures in the "Brief" edition and then, when you're ready to expand your competence and expertise further, you can take on the portions of the full edition you're already mostly familiar with. This is the process I followed and it provided a good introduction to Robert's Rules and a smooth gradient of learning the basics and then moving through to the full system.
At first, I referred exclusively to "In Brief" and carried it with me to meetings, leaving the full edition at home. Then, I began to have deeper questions and turned to the full edition, soon bringing BOTH "In Brief" and the full edition to meetings for quick reference during meetings--and deeper reference during breaks and temporary adjournments. Just a few meetings later, I realized that I knew virtually everything covered by "In Brief" and began referring exclusively to the full edition. That was very gratifying, believe me. I went on to become quite respected for my familiarity with this cornerstone of civil discourse and deliberation and was asked once by a Certified Parliamentarian--at a state-level political party convention no less--if I was a professional parliamentarian. A very fine result, by any measure.
You can have those results, too.
One major resource in getting through the ramp-up phase is covered in a book called "The Basic Study Manual". It's available here on Amazon. It shows you exactly what can trip you up or block you from learning a subject and shows you exactly what to do to keep moving. I wish I had been introduced to this book when I was a B- and C level (with the occasional D) student in high school. The results from this book, also, can be amazing.
So the basic principles are:
1. Results are far better when everyone uses the same reference. Think what would happen if you had two cooks making one spinach-and-bacon soufflé where each was following their own recipe.
2. Don't settle for imitations or knock-offs. Get the real thing--which means that it should be the current edition or immediately previous edition.
3. Get "Robert's Rules in Brief" AND "Robert's Rules Newly Revised" and start with "In Brief".
If you've read this far, I'll give you another tip (first of all, thanks for sticking with me). Due to the number of pages in the full edition of RONR, you will find that the PAPERBACK edition is more useful than the hardcover. You can look something up in the index, bend the paperback book to fan out the pages, and flip through them rapidly to go to your page number. This bend-and-flip method also works well when you're searching for a particular paragraph in an overall section that you've read before. The hardcover is good for your library, but the paperback makes a great handbook-type reference during "maneuvers" in the field.
I hope you've found this review of Robert's Rules helpful. It can be very gratifying to be able to help maintain order and forward progress in a meeting. Done properly, your colleagues and fellow members will thank you.