Commentaires client les plus utiles sur Amazon.com (beta)
Amazon.com:3.0 étoiles sur 5 1 commentaire
6 internautes sur 11 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile
3.0 étoiles sur 5Rather heavy on the pedantics, and too light on the aesthetics24 septembre 2007
Par Thomas J. Hickey - Publié sur Amazon.com
Format:Relié|Achat authentifié par Amazon
Rather heavy on the pedantics, and too light on the aesthetics
This book reads like a pedantic Ph.D. dissertation, or rather like three such dissertations sewn together into one bookbinding.
Part I is an economic and technology history of eighteenth-century decorative-arts production. It is an unlikely reason why anyone would purchase this high-gloss, coffee-table-style, oversized book.
Part II is a sociology of the layout and design of the Parisian noble's hôtel. It seems unlikely that these sociological considerations applied exclusively to the rococo period and not also to the ancien régime society of the preceding baroque and succeeding neoclassical styles.
Part III sets forth the historical thesis that political change in the form of the decline of monarchial absolutism reduced the status of the rococo style from noble status to commercially common, and thus brought about its eclipse. I find this an unsatisfactory explanation for the ascendancy of the neoclassical style.
Overall I found the book a disappointment. It shows little appreciation for the aesthetics of the style, which is quite charming. It has remarkably little color photography, and certainly too many black-and-white photos for such a book with a $90 price tag and only 318 pages.
Nonetheless I read the whole book more than once, and found some interesting historical material. I think that the title may be misleading. The book is a social and cultural history.
I refer readers interested in a better visual and aesthetic presentation of rococo interiors to Furniture: From Rococo to Art Deco (Evergreen Series). The latter has more than two and a third as many pages, at least a dozen times as many color photos including not just furniture but the room decorations as well, and about a fifth of the price.