This audiobook is set during season three, but is not actually an episode that was a part of that season. The things you hear are not things you will have seen on TV. It would seem "The Witchfinders" is set in the beginning of season three, after Robin's return to the land of the living, but before Guy gets carted off to Prince John, but unsure exactly when. This is based on the Sheriff being present, Isabella being absent and Guy being haunted by Marian's spirit. Oy vey, you should hear him angst about it. It's a real emo fest! And I love Guy even more for it.
Brood: check! Angst: Double-check!
The story is pretty good - hey, it's got witches! Or actually, it's got one suspected witch (Kate, haha!) - but the thing that strikes me the most is the reading itself. Richard Armitage can act, yes, but he gives every single character their own voice, and what's more, you recognise them from the show! Maybe not so much Marian and really not Tuck, but then again, Tuck was a newbie so the other actors hadn't heard him as much. You clearly hear Guy (obviously), the Scottish brogue of Little John, the cockney of Alan, the brusque Sheriff (a bit too brusque for my liking, he doesn't bark like that all the time), Robin, Kate, Much ... I was sitting in the car perfectly gobsmacked at the sheer skill with which he inhabits all the characters. It's amazing! Okay, the sound effects don't feel all that necessary, realistically, but wow, the reader's voice acting more than makes up for that.
So, the story. One of the Sheriff's soldiers mentions something about witches, and it gives the Sheriff an idea to solve the problem of Robin Hood: get a load of witchfinders and accuse Robin of witchcraft. The people are stupid enough to buy into that sort of thing, he reckons, and some witchfinders come along and seem very impressive. They can tell people things about dead relatives and whatnot (a very un-subtle cold reading), and a little girl says she's seen a witch, dancing with the devil in the forest: Kate. They test her with a fake needle and of course she feels no pain (it's retractable), so she's quickly whisked off to prison and the Outlaws have to try and find a way to get her out before she's tried and executed.
Meanwhile, Guy is hallucinating. He keeps seeing the ghost of Marian and she has issues with what he's done in the past and what he's doing to people now. She tries to make him realise that he might be a bad person, but he doesn't have to be, and he begins to listen to her, however reluctantly it is at first. She guilt-trips him something terribly and he's very emo about it all, like I said, but I love Emo Guy and the way this "episode" gives us a look inside his haunted mind ... it's everything a Guy fan could want.
The story fits in very well with season three. It adds an extra level of depth to the character of Guy and we realise exactly how much Marian's death is changing him. This story feels like a great big audio hug to me, and I've never been overly keen on the show itself in general. You have to listen to this, if you can get a hold of it.
As an added bonus, which made me all warm and fuzzy inside, it comes with a special feature (!): an interview with Richard Armitage at the end! They talk about Guy and Robin Hood and Marian's death and a lot of things. It's interesting and informative, and took me by surprise, as I had no idea it was there.