Commentaires en ligne 


2 évaluations
5 étoiles:    (0)
4 étoiles:
 (1)
3 étoiles:    (0)
2 étoiles:
 (1)
1 étoiles:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Moyenne des commentaires client
Partagez votre opinion avec les autres clients
Créer votre propre commentaire
 
 

Le commentaire favorable le plus utile
Le commentaire critique le plus utile


4.0 étoiles sur 5 "Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha, Stayin' Alive"
Read Susan Hill's 2008 novella "The Venetian Mask", describes a newly-married couple that loses its way in Venice with fatal consequences for the bridegroom. Her book celebrated the mystery of Venice throughout, but was it scary?

Read Ian McEwan's 2nd novel (1981) and shiver! It deals with Mary and Colin on a weeks-long holiday in Venice. They have been a...
Publié le 14 septembre 2012 par P. A. Doornbos

versus
2.0 étoiles sur 5 disappointing
Though I like McEwan, I found this book lacking the expected debt. Short, with plenty of irrelevant "leads" and a rather banal ending, it leaves one sorry to have spent time on it.
Publié le 1 novembre 2010 par Rudi Neirinckx


Du plus utile au moins utile | Du plus récent au plus ancien

4.0 étoiles sur 5 "Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha, Stayin' Alive", 14 septembre 2012
Ce commentaire fait référence à cette édition : The Comfort Of Strangers (Format Kindle)
Read Susan Hill's 2008 novella "The Venetian Mask", describes a newly-married couple that loses its way in Venice with fatal consequences for the bridegroom. Her book celebrated the mystery of Venice throughout, but was it scary?

Read Ian McEwan's 2nd novel (1981) and shiver! It deals with Mary and Colin on a weeks-long holiday in Venice. They have been a LAT-couple for 7 years, but are here and now inert, silent, unable to plan ahead or their daily lives: forgetting their city map, they lose their way every day. Written in a more languid voice than Susan Hill's, it is far more intrusive. Readers want to get a quick grip on a story, but McEwan does not allow this.

Divorced Mary has 2 children who stay with their dad in a UK commune. She acted in a now defunct woman's collective. Colin tried singing, then acting, no more about him or who paid the holiday, except that he looks cute. In my view, the couple is doomed from page 1. They do not act like normal tourists and fall prey to black-clad Robert, a guide, then owner of a basement gay bar with a jukebox emitting blue light. It blasts out again and again the same pumping, shrieking, sentimental song whose refrain of "Ha, ha, ha" is sung along loudly by the black-clad cruisers. Shortened by one `ha' for copyright reasons(?), the refrain and song must be the Bee Gees' "Stayin' Alive", a worldwide disco hit. And another clue about death foretold McEwan planted in his tale.

Read on to see how the trustful couple falls for the charms and fictions of Robert and his handicapped wife Caroline. It ends badly for the male hero (?) Colin, as in Susan Hill's book. Deep book that ends in blood and drama. Brr. On several counts, I rate McEwan's early story higher than Susan Hill's. Both books are rich in ideas and should be read more than once.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles 
Avez-vous trouvé ce commentaire utile ? Oui Non


2.0 étoiles sur 5 disappointing, 1 novembre 2010
Ce commentaire fait référence à cette édition : The Comfort Of Strangers (Broché)
Though I like McEwan, I found this book lacking the expected debt. Short, with plenty of irrelevant "leads" and a rather banal ending, it leaves one sorry to have spent time on it.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles 
Avez-vous trouvé ce commentaire utile ? Oui Non


Du plus utile au moins utile | Du plus récent au plus ancien

Ce produit

The Comfort Of Strangers
The Comfort Of Strangers de Ian McEwan (Broché - 5 juin 1997)
EUR 10,25
En stock
Ajouter au panier Ajouter à votre liste d'envies
Rechercher uniquement parmi les commentaires portant sur ce produit