Commentaires en ligne


2 évaluations
5 étoiles:
 (2)
4 étoiles:    (0)
3 étoiles:    (0)
2 étoiles:    (0)
1 étoiles:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Moyenne des commentaires client
Partagez votre opinion avec les autres clients
Créer votre propre commentaire
 
 
Du plus utile au moins utile | Du plus récent au plus ancien

4 internautes sur 4 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile 
5.0 étoiles sur 5 Absolument incontournable bien que déjà de 2001, 6 octobre 2011
Ce commentaire fait référence à cette édition : The Seven Daughters Of Eve (Broché)
That's an easy book to read even in spite of the highly scientific knowledge it is bringing because of the great care of the author, an Oxford scientific professor and researcher, to give us clear explanations and plenty of details.

The author is one of those who discovered and studied mitochondrial DNA back in the 1980s, carried out some of the essential research in the domain and proved some fundamental facts about the history of Homo Sapiens. The book was published in 2001 and it has aged on a couple of points but certainly not on the fundamental research on mitochondrial DNA.

Before presenting the essential results of his research, it is important to say that he explains in clear terms how his research at the beginning was going against the dominant theory and he gives details about the reactions of those who were defending the dominant theory of the time, how they reacted in a vastly hostile way though they had to concede defeat and accept the new theory but it took them quite a few years to come to that point, as if science was not the field of truth but the paternal domain of each scientist.

The main discovery was that 83% of the mitochondrial DNA of modern Europeans goes back to the first Homo Sapiens who arrived in Europe before the peak of the last glaciation and then backed up in front of the ice and stayed in the southern half of Europe before redeploying after the peak of that ice age. Only 17% of modern Europeans have a mitochondrial DNA coming from the Homo Sapiens that brought agriculture 10,000 years ago. That means that the Indo-European migration of the Neolithic was not an invasion, was not an overwhelming take-over but a very progressive advancement that was more the adoption of the new economic ways by the local population rather than the extinction of the older population or its total absorption by a massive migration of Indo-Europeans.

That means that before it was the theory of a massive invasion that was dominant.

The regret I have in front of this research is that the author and his team never considered the linguistic aspect of things. If the first Homo Sapiens in Europe were coming from Anatolia and if the Basques are the only still living descendants of this first population (proved by the blood characteristics of the Basques), that leads us to believe that the language of Cro-Magnon and the Gravettians was an agglutinative language of the Turkic family like Basque. If the Neolithic men who brought agriculture and herding into Europe from the Middle East bringing an economic model that will take over the whole continent it is also normal that their language or languages took over too, which means the present Indo-European languages of Europe are the languages of these Neolithic men and the Finno-Ugrian languages of Hungary, Finland, Estonia and a few other regions in Europe are the languages of a new migration of agglutinative speakers, this time from the Ural and still again in the Neolithic period.

The language question would have probably enabled them to understand that these Neolithic men were coming from the Middle East but not from the Levant since at the time of publication it was not yet known the Levant had no Homo Sapiens occupants from 80,000 years ago to 35,000 years ago, the period of the first Homo Sapiens migration to Europe. They did not come from Africa via the Sinai but via another route which was not known in 2001 but is perfectly known today. But the language question would have led them to doubt the Levantine origin of these Neolithic men because these men brought Indo-European languages into Europe and the Levant was speaking a range of Semitic languages.

It is fascinating to follow this research and position it precisely before 2001. The shortcomings and flaws of it are due to things they could not know before 2001. First the southern coastal corridor along the coast of the Arabian Peninsula for the agglutinative and Indo-Aryan-Indo-European languages, or a route slightly north of this coastal route and across the Arabian Peninsula. Second they would have been able to think that the Middle East we are speaking of here, Mesopotamia and the Iranian plateau were occupied by languages (Sumerian is the oldest known language of this area and group) that developed into agglutinative languages that will be brought into Europe by Cro-Magnon 45,000 years ago, and later into the Indo-Aryan and Indo-European languages that will migrate from the Iranian plateau to India for the former and to Europe for the latter.

But The research presented in this book is absolutely positive about all humanity being born in the Eastern part of Africa (Kenya, Ethiopia, Somalia) and then having migrated from there within Africa (and here the book does not speak at all of the Khoesian languages and the Semitic languages) and then out of Africa via the Middle East (essentially Mesopotamia, the Iranian plateau and eventually the valleys and plains of Pakistan) to the rest of the world. This research proved that at world level 33 mitochondrial DNA clans can be identified, 13 of them being African, the others being all over the world. As for Europe 7 mitochondrial DNA clans can be identified, six of them (83% of the population) that can be traced back to Cro-Magnon and his direct descendants, and one that can be traced to Asia Minor Neolithic time. That is a phenomenal result.

We just have to cross this research with research on the phylogeny of language and the psychogenesis of language to understand the various and successive waves of human migrations out of Africa. But that is linguistic research and that is where I am working. You cannot imagine how happy I am in discovering this book that supports my own research and justifies some of my purely linguistic hypotheses.

This is a classic that everyone who is looking for our distant history should read at least three times and upon which they should meditate at least till they reach the linguistic and humanistic nibbana (sorry nirvana in Sanskrit) of Enlightenment.

Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles 
Avez-vous trouvé ce commentaire utile ? Oui Non


3 internautes sur 3 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile 
5.0 étoiles sur 5 FASCINANT !, 24 novembre 2009
Ce commentaire fait référence à cette édition : The Seven Daughters Of Eve (Broché)
Extraordinaire aventure au coeur du monde génétique dans un langage accessible à tous. Nous descendons tous de 7 Femmes sources, berceau de l'humanité mis en évidence par les dernières avancées scientifiques. J'ai adoré ce livre qui m'ouvre de nouveaux horizons sur la compréhension de notre espèce.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles 
Avez-vous trouvé ce commentaire utile ? Oui Non


Du plus utile au moins utile | Du plus récent au plus ancien

Ce produit

Rechercher uniquement parmi les commentaires portant sur ce produit