|
7 internautes sur 7 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile
Ce commentaire fait référence à cette édition : Les vacances de M. Hulot - version restaurée (DVD)
As a big fan of Tati's work, I couldn't resist the chance of seeing the restored version of his 1953 masterpiece, and on a trip to France I managed to pick up a copy on DVD.Little did I know that the BFI DVD version I have been watching 'en Angleterre' was in fact a re-issue from 1978, with a different score, shortened length, and new jokes added. Whilst watching the lovingly cleaned picture and sound, I assumed that restoring the final edit of Tati's is in keeping with the 'auteur' theory, and although purists will sniff at not preserving his first version, should honour his creative decision to continually finesse his work, as he did when re-releasing 'Jour de Fete' in 1964. The extras on the DVD are comprehensive, and as long as you are armed with a basic grasp of 'la langue' - as you can plainly read, like myself - the lack of English subtitles will not hamper your enjoyment. My only gripe with the DVD is the way the 4:3 format is presented. In 2010, it is very likely you will have a 16:9 TV, and naturally you will have the DVD/Blu-ray player set to match it. Unfortunately this combination cuts off the top and the bottom of the frame to fit the screen, and to be honest I spent twenty minutes changing the TV settings and spitting feathers, thinking that the French had gone mad and butchered their own classic film! To fix it, you will have to send your player back 10 years and set the format to a 4:3 TV, with the 'letterbox' function switched on. This also applies to some of the special features. Once you have sorted that, 'Bonnes Vacances!' Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles Remarques
Suivi en cours par 2 clients
Classer par: Le plus ancien d'abord | Le plus récent d'abord
Afficher les messages 1-7 sur 7 de cette discussion.
Message initial:
20 nov. 10 11:23:05 GMT+01:00
Dernière modification par l'auteur le 20 nov. 10 11:23:55 GMT+01:00
C. Nogueira dit:
Les remarques sur le format du DVD faites par ce Tati-lover me laissent un peu perplexe. Les lois de la géometrie nous disent qu'il n'y a que 2 façons de mettre un carré dans un rectangle, tout en gardant leurs formes respectives: soit le carré couvre le rectangle entièrement et on perd le haut et le bas du carré, soit le rectangle couvre le carré totalement et il nous restent visibles les deux côtés du rectangle. As simple as that.
En réponse à un message antérieur du
17 déc. 10 12:39:47 GMT+01:00
mannig dit:
Sorry, but what a stupid guy You are ! You want stretch a 4:3 Film to have a full videoscreen on Your BIG WIDE MODERN flat-tv ? Letterbox shows the view of an widescreen format movie on 4:3 tv.
En réponse à un message antérieur du
23 janv. 11 15:32:42 GMT+01:00
kenjuro@another.com dit:
Dear Mannig,
Apologies if my review was unclear to the point where you had to insult someone. The film is presented in 4:3, encoded anamorphically to 16:9. The review: "DVD 1 : version restaurée - 1.37, 16/9, 88 min. mono" As you said, I have a BIG WIDE MODERN 16:9 TV with a Blu-ray player, so that either one or the other adjusts the picture to show it in it's natural ratio. In this case, it should have pillarboxed the picture to 4:3. When you play this DVD, these particular settings crop off the top and the bottom of the frame, filling the 16:9 screen and cuts off the top of people's heads and the subtitles at the bottom. Adjusting the TV's picture setting does not fix this, so you have to change the settings in the Blu-ray player to 'letterbox', and only then it will be 4:3 pillarboxed. Many thanks.
En réponse à un message antérieur du
14 févr. 11 08:18:31 GMT+01:00
[Supprimé par l'auteur le 17 févr. 11 12:04:23 GMT+01:00]
En réponse à un message antérieur du
17 févr. 11 12:12:11 GMT+01:00
john-claude dit:
I do understand what you are talking about Kenjuro.
If it's of some help, I have found that my Blu-ray player will only play to the 16.9 ratio, however my DVD player will display the correct original format ie 4.3 within the 16.9 window. Cheers jc
En réponse à un message antérieur du
5 mars 11 18:29:09 GMT+01:00
kenjuro@another.com dit:
Thank you for that, and to make things worse the blu-ray has come out in the UK with both versions on!
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Vacances-M-Hulot-Blu-ray-DVD/dp/B0041HL5GQ/ref=sr_1_6?s=dvd
En réponse à un message antérieur du
6 janv. 12 16:21:08 GMT+01:00
Olivier Comte dit:
Mr Kenjuro is right.
Some restorations, in BluRay, even in DVD/SD offer an 1,33/1,37 or 1,66 ratio through an 16x9 anamorphic transfer. Unfortunately, most older TV sets who display 1,78/1,85 or 2.0, 2.2, 2.35, 2.55 correctly and within the 16x9 setting will display 1,66 or 1,85 ratios for the newer discs. You need to have a set with a special, or automatic setting. MADAME DE was recently shown, by Ciné... in that 1,33 ratio,16x9 setting. The same goes for the Blu Ray Bogart movies, The Wizard of Oz, Gone With the Wind, Quo Vadis... The http://Amazon.co.uk presentation of the BR BFI edition is not clear about the ratio and seems to indicate that you can't go without English subtitles.
‹ Précédent 1 Suivant ›
|
Détails de l'évaluationArticle
EUR 20,74
Commentateur
![]() Lieu : Cumbria, England
Classement des meilleurs critiques: 125.448 |